Back to How Not To Suck At Divorce

Podcast Episode

Divorce: The Petty Fights That Cost You Thousands. What Top Attorneys Want You to Know...

How Not To Suck At Divorce·Morgan Stogsdill and Andrea Rappaport·11 September 2026·45 min

About this episode

Guided Divorce MeditationsIf you’re stuck in a divorce fight that is making you anxious, angry, or completely unable to think clearly, start here.Our Guided Divorce Meditations are designed for the moments when you need to regulate your nervous system before you respond, negotiate, argue, or make another expensive decision.Divorce Crash CourseGoing through divorce and wondering what you should fight for, what you should let go, and how to avoid making expensive mistakes?Our Divorce Crash Course is a private podcast and guidebook designed to help you understand the divorce process, make smarter decisions, and avoid costly emotional mistakes.Typically priced at $150, it’s available now for $50, thanks to our angel underwriters OurFamilyWizard and Soberlink.Episode Show NotesPeople spend thousands of dollars fighting over some truly ridiculous things in divorce.A wooden spoon. A blender. A sixth-grade yearbook. Beanie Babies. Airline miles. Even a tanning bed.And as funny as those stories sound, there is a very real reason they matter.Because most of the time, the thing you are fighting over is not actually the thing you are fighting over.In this episode of How Not to Suck at Divorce, Andrea Rappaport and family law attorney Morgan Stogsdill are joined by attorneys Sarah Jacobs and Jamie Berger of Jacobs Berger for a conversation about the emotional and financial cost of digging in during divorce. One client spent hours in court fighting over a wooden spoon named Willy Woo. Another divorce came down to a battle over a blender. And one case required attorneys to spend days sorting through tubs of Beanie Babies because neither side could let them go. The stories are absurd.The behavior behind them is not.Divorce Can Turn Small Things Into Expensive BattlesWhen you are going through divorce, emotion can completely distort value.An object may be worth $100, but suddenly it represents your marriage, your history, your independence, your power, or your need to finally “win.”That is where people start spending far more in attorney fees than the thing they are fighting over is actually worth.In the episode, Andrea points out that the fight over one wooden spoon likely cost thousands of dollars in legal fees alone. And that is exactly why divorce strategy matters.Before you dig in, you have to ask yourself:What is this actually worth?Not emotionally.Financially.The Real Problem May Be ControlSometimes the fight is not about property at all.Morgan explains that many of these so-called “squirrel issues” ultimately come down to control. When someone feels like they have lost control of their life, their finances, their family, or the divorce process itself, they may try to regain that feeling of control by pushing the other person’s buttons. Sarah adds that fear can drive the same behavior: fear of change, fear of being alone, fear of losing the life you knew, and fear of what comes next. That means the blender may not be about the blender.The yearbook may not be about the yearbook.And the airline miles may not be about the airline miles.Sometimes the fight itself has become a way to stay connected to the relationship, hold onto control, or avoid confronting the much bigger reality that the marriage is ending.Principle Has a Price TagOne of the strongest lines in this episode comes from Jamie:Principle has a price tag.If you are fighting over something purely because you believe you are right, you need to understand what that principle is going to cost you.That cost may be financial.It may also be emotional.You can absolutely decide that something matters enough to fight for. But that decision should be intentional—not reactive.Jamie recommends being honest with yourself and with your attorney about what truly matters to you and why. Treat Divorce Like a Business TransactionMorgan’s advice is simple: do the math.Take the emotion out of the issue for a moment and write down the actual numbers.What is the item worth?What would it cost to replace?How many hours will your attorney spend fighting over it?How much will those hours cost?What are you potentially giving up in order to get it?Sometimes seeing those numbers on paper is enough to change your perspective. That does not mean divorce is emotionless.It means your decisions should not be controlled by those emotions.Give Your Attorney the “Shark Tank” PitchSarah offers another test:If you are determined to fight for something, explain why it matters in a way that would actually sound reasonable to a judge.Sell the argument.Explain the value.Explain what you are willing to give up in exchange.If you cannot make the case convincingly to your own attorney, you may want to reconsider whether this is really the hill you want to die on. And that matters beyond the object itself.Being unreasonable about a relatively small issue can affect how your position is perceived when the court is dealing with things that matter much more—support, custody, property division, or settlement.Ask Yourself What This Will Matter Five Years From NowThis may be the most useful perspective shift in the entire episode.Five years from now, are you going to care who got the blender?Are you really going to remember the airline miles?Will winning the fight over a piece of furniture have made your post-divorce life meaningfully better?Probably not.Andrea shares her own experience of losing a baby blanket she had slept with since birth—something she once believed she could never live without. A decade later, she is still standing. That is not to minimize the emotional meaning of possessions.It is to remind you that you are capable of letting go.Three Questions to Ask Before You FightBefore you spend another dollar arguing over something in your divorce, do three things.First, ask yourself why this matters so much.Second, do the math and compare the value of the item to the cost of fighting for it.Third, if you still want it, make the case. Explain why it matters, what it is worth, and what you are willing to give up to get it.If you cannot answer those questions clearly, it may not be worth the fight. Because getting divorced is already expensive enough.You do not need to make it more expensive just to prove a point.In This EpisodeAndrea, Morgan, Sarah, and Jamie discuss ridiculous divorce fights, how emotional attachment can drive up legal fees, why control and fear fuel unnecessary conflict, when possessions really are worth negotiating over, how mediation can help rein in a case, and how to make smarter financial decisions during divorce.They also tackle one critical question:Is this thing actually valuable—or are you just trying to win?SEO Keywordsdivorce mistakes, expensive divorce mistakes, what to fight for in divorce, divorce legal fees, divorce strategy, fighting over assets in divorce, divorce property division, emotional divorce decisions, high conflict divorce, divorce settlement strategy, divorce mediation, divorce attorney fees, divorce negotiation tips, divorce financial mistakes, dividing property in divorce