Podcast Episode
Recruiting Isn't Fair - It's Competitive
Football 360 Show: NIL, D1 recruiting, Transfer portal, Athletic Development, Strength Training.Β·Football 360 ShowΒ·18 February 2026Β·47 min

About this episode
π§ Show Overview
On this episode of the Football 360 Show, J.P. Rock and Matt Biermann dive deep into the realities of football recruiting, the mindset required for long-term success, and why families must take ownership of the process instead of hoping it "just happens."
From middle school combines to NIL economics, this episode pulls back the curtain on what athletes and parents are truly up against.
π Where to Listen
π football360show.com
π₯ Live on X & YouTube
ποΈ Podcast on Spotify & Apple Podcasts
π§ Main Topics & Takeaways
1οΈβ£ Recruiting Is NOT Automatic
Playing high school football does not guarantee a college opportunity.
Many families underestimate the time commitment required.
Some athletes who sign D1 scholarships have families investing 20β40 hours per month into promotion, communication, and strategy.
You need:
A plan
A framework
Consistent outreach
Accountability
"Hope is not a strategy."
2οΈβ£ Truth Over Comfort
Coaches evaluate players harshly.
There is no "parent bias" at the college level.
Families need honest assessments β even when uncomfortable.
Many people in the recruiting space tell athletes what they want to hear, not what they need to hear.
3οΈβ£ The Push & Pull Recruiting Strategy
Success requires:
π€ Proactive outreach (emails, follow-ups, camp invites)
π₯ Tracking engagement (who opened emails, who responded)
π Organization of communication
π
Understanding NCAA contact timelines
For example:
Coaches cannot respond to freshmen/sophomores during certain periods.
Communication opens up significantly after sophomore summer.
If you don't understand timing, you're already behind.
π Middle School Combine Insights
Matt discusses the recent Elite Football Middle School Combine and why events like this matter early.
Why It Matters:
Kids learn how to test.
They get comfortable competing.
They build resiliency.
They establish benchmarks.
Unlike high school events, middle school athletes:
Show up
Run their times
Compete
Don't hide from testing
"At some point, you have to run."
π Benchmarking & Development
Athletes were encouraged to:
Compare results within their grade.
Compare results to older athletes.
Set goals based on real data.
Use testing as a development tool β not a fear trigger.
Testing reveals truth. Avoiding it delays growth.
β Player Examples: Different Paths to Success
Two former Elite athletes illustrate the spectrum of elite performance:
πββοΈ Kyren Williams
Not the biggest.
Not a pure straight-line burner.
Extremely elusive.
Elite agility & vision.
Now a Pro Bowl-level NFL player.
πββοΈ Jeremiah Love
Bigger frame.
True sprinter.
Explosive and dynamic.
Also thriving at Notre Dame.
Lesson: There is no single prototype.
But you must fit someone's evaluation criteria.
π§ Mindset Wins Long-Term
Resiliency is mandatory.
You will get beat on reps.
You will throw bad passes.
You will fail tests.
You will be mis-evaluated.
What matters:
Do you respond?
Do you improve?
Do you compete again?
π Position Reality Check
Many athletes lock into a position identity too early.
Common example:
Athlete insists on playing defensive line.
Body type, movement, and mindset scream offensive line.
Coaches will project you where they see value β not where you prefer.
"You play where coaches want you to play."
π° The Business of College Football
Discussion turns toward the economics of college athletics:
Football and basketball generate revenue.
Many other sports operate at losses.
NIL and revenue distribution are reshaping the landscape.
The gap between football and other sports continues to widen.
A semi-professional licensing model similar to MLS may eventually emerge.
College football