Podcast Episode
INDIANA - Western Kentucky Postgame LIVE

About this episode
Indiana–Western Kentucky Postgame LIVE
IndianaVOCFB | Host: Alec Keezer | Guests: Sammy Jacobs (Hoosier Huddle / radio stats) & Jamie Jordan (Crimson Audible / Hoosier Huddle)
Presented by FanDuel | ~73 minutes
Intro & Format (0:32–1:31)
Keezer flying solo without Brad. Guests: Sammy (insider — sits next to Don Fisher on the radio broadcast) and Jamie (outsider/couch view).
Quick Red Sox aside (clinched), then straight into Hoosiers. Time crunch with Sammy, so they jump in with insider vs. outsider framing.
Josh Hoover: Perception vs. Reality (1:31–9:20)
Biggest timeline topic. Sammy: hot-take society + instant-coach culture. Three bad throws cost IU points; if Hoover hits one or two, it’s 52-0 talk instead of 38-0. Off-target throws also showed up vs. North Texas and in spring. Margin is inches (Tyler Morris example).
EPA/snap numbers still elite even with limited volume (~52 attempts in 3 games). People forget Mendoza’s warts (Iowa, Oregon, Penn State near-pick, title-game throw that hit a Miami defender).
Jamie: Hoover looks similar on paper to Rourke/Mendoza but misses throws he can make. Cignetti pulled receivers after the game and took the blame. High standard because Hoover has 10k yards and ~80 TDs in his career.
Not just Hoover: Nick Marsh drop, tight-end blocking (one catch all year), right-side OL not matching Drew Evans, third-down issues, run game. Defense missed-tackle rate up (15% this year vs. 11% last year; 13% through three last season). Still “very much in” on the team — 8-4 talk is noise.
Defense: Tackling, Alignment, Personnel (9:20–14:23)
Sammy: lots of different looks from opponents; IU playing a lot of soft zone, rarely blitzing. WKU put 20 on Georgia in Sanford; IU hasn’t allowed a point since Labor Day. Isaiah Jones adjusting to green-dot. D’Angelo Ponce irreplaceable vs. the run and in coverage. Jamari Sharp back after limited snaps; AJ Harris only 7 snaps all year.
Pressure was there (9 hurries) even if only one sack — mobile QB escaping. DL (Farrell, Baldwin, etc.) still good. Issues in flats/quick outs behind LBs. Less SIM pressure than last year; Cignetti respecting Northwestern and not showing the full package yet.
Jamie: still winning and shutting teams out, but need to see the actual scheme. Extra reps for corners helpful. Biggest preseason question was replacing Ponce/Fisher/Kamara.
Tight End Room (14:23–17:09)
First drive heavy on true freshman Trevor Gibbs (banged up in camp, missed first two games). Looked like a freshman early. Barker got the official start and they moved the ball better with him. Snap counts: Shot 24, Gibbs 18, Barker 26.
Room has almost no experience (three total games, one of them one snap). Building the plane while flying it. Gibbs has the body to block; Shot better as a receiver; they’re trying to turn Gibbs into a Nowakowski-type. Trust staff to figure it out.
Most Impressive Player Through 3 Weeks (17:09–19:56)
Both: Turbo Richard. 149 rushing yards, long runs, kick-return threat (opponents scared to kick to him — extra 15 yards of field position). Slippery, falls forward, hard to square up. Bebe “all right” but lacks the burst.
Jamie shout-outs: Otsun Sami and Obizer on the DL — underrated, hard to block on obvious passing downs.
Biggest Leap Into Conference Play (19:56–23:12)
Sammy: Nick Marsh. Breakout game despite fumble (recovered) and plays he wants back. Beast blocker. Offseason vision of Becker + Marsh being uncoverable. Still learning the program.
Jamie: same room — Davion Chandler. Wiggle, YAC monster (4 catches, 3 TDs early). Cignetti already listed him in the top four. Thickness + quickness like Omar Cooper. Depth to spell Becker/Marsh/Morris/Preston is huge.
Charlie Becker, Heisman Odds, Punt Returns (23:12–27:20)
Becker +12,500 Heisman on FanDuel. 12 catches, 6 TDs. Hoover “punt” throw to him was the least egregious miss — Becker was wide open and outran everyone.
Punt returns: Cignetti said they were giving Tyler Morris a breather. Jamie not panicked long-term but doesn’t love the long-limbed star getting rolled up. Special-teams culture (Burnham covering/catching kicks) is a Cignetti trademark. Morris drops happened; just get him back on the horse.
Defense Sack Total / Pressure (27:20–early 40s, scattered)
One sack doesn’t match the tape — they were in the backfield constantly. Same “no sacks early” narrative as last year with Kamara. Otsun Sami freeze celebration after a TFL was a highlight.
True/False Rapid Fire
Best WR room Cignetti has had at Indiana? True at the top (Becker/Marsh first-round caliber), false at the bottom. Chandler emerging as the fifth. Cignetti himself pointed back to the 2024 depth (McCulley couldn’t get on the field).
Michigan toughest road game? True. Defense is good; scoring is the question. Underwood talent vs. “between the ears.” Week 1 look was ugly, Oklahoma bounce-back better.
Best defense of the Brian Haynes era? Talent-wise yes, and it can get there. Harder to replace Ponce/Fisher than expected. Back-to-back shutouts first time since 1993. Scheme growth still coming.
Should add a Power 4 non-con? Should, but don’t need to. Other sports use exhibitions; football needs competitive tape without the injury risk of extra regular-season games.
Right not to worry about Hoover? Yes. Four throws aside he was good. Happy feet / seeing it too early and throwing off-platform. Run game getting going in the second half will help. Broken-nose theory after helmet-to-dirt hit — he’s fine, just a gunslinger who thinks he can make every throw from every platform.
Jerrion Campbell RB3? Yes in the hierarchy. Wind knocked out; Kuno played more and looked night-and-day better than vs. Howard. Campbell vision + falls-forward style. Committee of Bebe/Richard then the next two.
2028 class better than 2027? Yes. Lucas Prok/Brock (Hun School) already spinning it like a five-star, video-game numbers, processes like a much older QB. 2027 still loved for immediate impact.
Should be Big Ten favorites? Should be, aren’t getting the respect. Ohio State more loaded and young/athletic. Rankings dummy who perpetually buries IU is a bit at this point.
Other Notes & Weekend Watch
WR blocking: Marsh 25-yard-downfield block on Richard’s late run — knew when to let go so it wasn’t holding. “No block, no rock.” Chandler also inserted between guard/tackle.
Recruiting momentum on 2028 offers.
Jamie (Massachusetts roots): UMass 3-0 after beating Stonehill (didn’t cover); BC beat Rutgers on Wells Crowther/red-bandana night.
Keezer at Miss State–South Carolina: Kamario Taylor “holy cow” — howitzer arm, athletic, wide-choice offense perfect for him. Needs to harness touch on intermediate throws (Mendoza comparison). LaNorris Sellers one of the worst INT throws he’s seen live.
Northwestern–Penn State next for Jamie (new stadium, family ties). Northwestern looked scrappier than the Colorado score; Colorado left points on the field.
Close (1:10+)
Crimson Audible Wednesday nights (~9 CT / 10 ET). Hoosier Huddle. IndianaVOCFB chasing 1,000 YouTube subs (215 away). Keezer + Brad back Tuesday for Indiana–Northwestern.
Go Hoosiers.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.