Back to The Cabbage Coins Podcast

Podcast Episode

Ep.54 - Valuing Colorful Morgan Dollars Pt.2 w/Jacob Matiyevsky #coincollecting #silver #rarecoins

The Cabbage Coins Podcast··19 August 2026·43 min

About this episode

In this episode, Jacob Matiyevsky shares his expertise on coin toning, focusing on how to evaluate the expected premium of toned Morgan dollars and other coins. Listeners will learn about different types of toning, market values, and what makes a coin a 'monster' in the numismatic world.Chapters00:00 Introduction to coin toning and market insights 02:02 Evaluating premiums based on toning quality 04:06 Examples of high-end toned Morgan dollars 06:05 Identifying terminal toning and its effects 08:10 The significance of vibrant colors and pattern 09:51 What makes a coin a 'monster' in toning 12:01 Market value ranges for different toning levels 14:02 The role of auction venues and private sales 16:08 The importance of color, luster, and pattern in valuation 18:05 Special types of toning: end roll and bag toning 20:06 How coin condition and grade influence value 22:09 The rarity and market for toned Morgan dollars 23:53 The appeal of proof gold and other rare coins 26:14 The impact of grade on high-value coins 27:54 Market trends and where to buy or sell toned coins 30:00 The importance of photography and presentation 31:58 Final thoughts on collecting and valuing toned coinsWhere to find Tony and Cabbage Coins: https://cabbagecoins.com/ Email: tony@cabbagecoins.com IG: @cabbage_coinsWhere to find Jacob and Monster Toned Morgans: https://www.monstertonedmorgans.com/ IG: @monstertonedmorgans Email: monstertonedmorgans@gmail.comUpcoming coin show schedule: https://cabbagecoins.com/coinshows/Thanks for watching. Please be sure to like, comment and subscribe!