Back to Other Peoples Parenting

Podcast Episode

'Yesteryear': A Journey Through Parenting and Identity

Other Peoples Parenting··6 August 2026·52 min

About this episode

Think your morning routine is chaotic? At least you aren’t churning butter in 1855. Let’s talk Yesteryear.This week’s episode dives into a book that has been dominating our book clubs, social media feeds, and group chats. We are talking about Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke. This is a fictional story that critiques contemporary parenting dynamics through the lens of a trad-wife influencer who grapples with her curated online persona and the reality of her unhappy existence. Does this remind you of anyone or anything…Hannah Neeleman of Ballerina Farm perhaps?In Yesteryear, we meet Natalie, a glamorous, high-profile influencer who runs Yesteryear Ranch. On the outside, she is the ultimate tradwife — she bakes sourdough from scratch, wears gorgeous vintage dresses, has a beautiful family, and claims she is quite literally perfect at being alive.As modern moms, we all know that behind every perfectly carefully edited, aesthetic grid post, there is a chaotic reality. In this book, the line between performance and reality doesn't just blur—it fractures. The story takes us back and forth between Natalies modern, expertly selected and presented online life and a mysterious, grueling 1855 pioneer timeline, building up incredible psychological suspense that asks a massive question: What happens to a mother when the pressure to maintain a perfect illusion completely takes over?Whether you love scrolling through lifestyle influencers for inspiration, or you find yourself longing for a simpler life, this book holds up a fascinating, dark mirror to modern motherhood. Join us as we consider the societal pressures on women within the context of traditional and modern roles and discuss Natalie’s eventual unraveling as she confronts the absurdities of her lifestyle choices. So, grab your coffee or a glass of wine and let's talk about Yesteryear.Takeaways:This episode dives into the complexities of parenting as portrayed in the fictional narrative of Yesteryear.The discussion emphasizes the impact of societal expectations on women's roles in both contemporary and historical contexts.An exploration of mental health themes is evident, highlighting the struggles of the protagonist amidst societal pressures.The contrasting lifestyles of traditional and modern parenting are examined, raising questions about personal fulfillment and societal norms. Links referenced in this episode:TestingMom.comBallerinaFarm.comKissingMom.comHabitCoach.com Companies mentioned in this episode:Habit CoachBallerina FarmYesteryear RanchRuby FrankieTesting Mom