Back to True Crime Obsessed

Podcast Episode

The Christian Mother Who Executed Her Husband for Eight Hundred Thousand Dollars

True Crime Obsessed··26 May 2026·20 min

About this episode

A respected Christian mother in her church called 911 asking for help for her dying husband. She herself had shot him the final blow. How did a woman who taught religion to children plan the murder of the father of her children for eight hundred thousand dollars, a forged policy, and an ex-military man with a classified past? In this episode, you will discover how a clandestine affair inside a Baptist church turned into a cold-blooded murder plot. You will learn about the contradictions that sank her version of masked attackers, the policy that changed hands mysteriously, and how a piece of underwear became evidence of a planned escape to Mexico. From the first shot to her death sentence, every detail reveals a double life that the church never saw coming. Case Details Victim: Robert Andrew, 43 years old, insurance agency vice president Date: November 20, 2001 Location: Oklahoma, United States Status: Brenda Andrew sentenced to death (2004); sentence pending after international precautionary measures (2024). Jim Pavat sentenced to death (2003); execution confirmed. - Robert changed the beneficiary of his policy to his brother after discovering cut brakes, but the active policy at the time of the crime showed Brenda as the sole beneficiary - who forged the document and when? - Brenda detailed the crime to an inmate in pretrial detention, but her defense claimed gender bias based on stereotypes of a Christian mother, not on forensic evidence - why was her own confession ignored in appeals? - Jim claimed to be a former special forces agent and classified military official, but his records were never publicly confirmed - what was his true identity and connections? - The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights issued precautionary measures in 2024 alleging risk of imminent execution, but Oklahoma rejected its authority - is there legal space for both to