Back to True Crime Obsessed

Podcast Episode

The Police Officer, the iPhone, and Three Years of Silence

True Crime Obsessed··26 May 2026·23 min

About this episode

A police officer was in Sandra's apartment three minutes before her iPhone recorded her last movements. That night, Sandra was found dead and authorities closed it as a suicide within hours. How did an entire system decide not to see what was in front of its eyes for over three years? In this episode, you will discover how 32,000 messages revealed a relationship that began when Sandra was 13 years old, how a broken necklace and phone data became the evidence that no one wanted to investigate, and why a police chief and the FBI had to act when the local system refused to look. A story of institutional cover-up, systematic abuse, and the technology that finally spoke the truth. Case Details Victim: Sandra Birmore, 20 years old, participant in the Explorers program Date: February 1, 2021 (date of death) Location: Stoughton, Massachusetts, United States Status: Matthew Farwell arrested August 28, 2024, federally charged with killing a witness, trial scheduled for October 2026 - Documented sexual relationship started April 2013 when Sandra was 13-14 years old, contradicts Matthew's statement to police about January 2020 - Messages analyzed by Stoughton PD reveal a pattern of violence: 20 references to strangulation and sexual asphyxiation, while previous state analysis concludes no threats - Surveillance video shows a hooded man entering at 21:14 and leaving at 21:43, exactly coinciding with the last movements of Sandra's iPhone recorded at 21:40 - Dr. William Smock's expert report establishes a fracture of the hyoid bone incompatible with hanging: final ruling is homicide by asphyxiation, not suicide How did three years pass before anyone decided to listen to what Sandra's phone had already recorded? covered-up homicide, child abuse, corrupt police, Explorers program, Stoughton Massachusetts, broken necklace evidence, iPhone forensic data, FBI inve