Loading…
🔪 Curated Collection
Podcasts Like My Favorite Murder
The perfect blend of comedy and true crime — the highest-rated shows for fans who like their murder with a side of laughter.
Want something more personal? Take the quiz and we'll match you to the perfect show.
30 podcasts like my favorite murder podcasts — the big names
Good Hang with Amy Poehler
The Ringer
Last Podcast On The Left
The Last Podcast Network
Lore
Aaron Mahnke
The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart
Comedy Central
Ologies with Alie Ward
Alie Ward
Hello From The Magic Tavern
Arnie Niekamp
The NoSleep Podcast
Creative Reason Media Inc.
The Black Tapes
Pacific Northwest Stories
How To Fail With Elizabeth Day
Elizabeth Day and Sony Music Entertainment
Beautiful Stories From Anonymous People
Chris Gethard
Duncan Trussell Family Hour
Duncan Trussell Family Hour
Deep Water | Tortoise Investigates
The Observer
The Girls Bathroom
Sophia & Cinzia
The 85 South Show with Karlous Miller, DC Young Fly and Chico Bean
The Black Effect and iHeartPodcasts
Andrew Schulz's Flagrant with Akaash Singh
Andrew Schulz's Flagrant with Akaash Singh
Elis James and John Robins
BBC Radio 5 Live
Not Gonna Lie with Kylie Kelce
Wave
KILL TONY
DEATHSQUAD.TV & Studio71
National Park After Dark
Audioboom Studios
Sounds Like A Cult
Studio71
Wolf & Owl with Romesh Ranganathan and Tom Davis
Mighty Ranga / Keep It Light Media
Love and Radio
Love and Radio | QCODE
Club Random with Bill Maher
Bill Maher
The Horror of Dolores Roach
Gimlet
Omnibus
Omnibus
Talk Tuah with Haliey Welch
16 Minutes
Carefully Reckless
The Black Effect and iHeartPodcasts
IHIP News
Jennifer Welch & Angie Sullivan
Give It To Me Straight
Dear Media
The Athletic NBA Daily
The Athletic
How we curate podcasts like my favorite murder
Every podcast on WhichPodcast is ranked using Listen Score — a global popularity metric based on listener data, episode frequency, and audience engagement across Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube. The shows above are drawn from the genres most relevant to this collection and sorted by their global listener ranking, so the top results reflect what millions of real listeners are choosing right now.
Want a more personalised recommendation? Our podcast discovery quiz matches you to the right show based on your mood, your time, and whether you want a household name or a hidden gem.
Frequently asked questions
What podcasts are similar to My Favorite Murder?
My Favorite Murder pioneered the 'comedy true crime' genre — two hosts discussing real crimes with humour and irreverence. The best similar shows combine genuine true crime research with comedic hosts who don't take themselves too seriously. The top-ranked shows above are the most popular picks among MFM fans.
Is the comedy true crime genre appropriate?
Comedy true crime podcasts handle the tension between humour and respect for victims differently — the best shows are careful to punch at criminals and systems, not victims. Listeners of the genre are generally very engaged in true crime and use humour as a coping mechanism for dark subject matter.